St. Johns County, Florida, is the fastest-growing county in the state, with a population increase of 24.1% between 2014-2018 and 2019-2023. This rapid expansion has increased housing demand, raised property values, and created a booming rental market.
What if you could secure a property in St. Johns County that consistently appreciates in value?
Beyond its growing population, St. Johns County offers top-rated schools, resort-style amenities, and easy access to downtown Jacksonville. These factors continue to attract families, professionals, and retirees, ensuring long-term demand for housing. Additionally, the county's proximity to beautiful beaches, nature preserves, and high-end shopping centers makes it even more desirable for residents and investors.
With rising property values and increasing demand, now is the perfect time to invest in St. Johns County. Whether you're looking for a rental property, a vacation home, or a long-term investment, this market has something for everyone. Let’s explore the best neighborhoods for real estate investors in St. Johns County, Florida, that offer great opportunities in 2025.
1. Julington Creek Plantation – A Master-Planned Community with Resort-Style Living
Julington Creek Plantation is one of the most well-established communities in St. Johns County, offering an attractive blend of suburban comfort and high-end amenities, such as:
- Resort-style swimming pools
- A fitness center
- An aquatic complex
- Golf courses
- Tennis courts
- Skate park
- Nature trails
It's home to two large amenity centers and boasts top-rated schools, making it an ideal location for families seeking long-term rental properties. Investors can choose from diverse property options, including single-family homes at various prices.
Investment Potential: With increasing home values and continued demand for family-friendly housing, Julington Creek Plantation is a solid long-term investment.
2. Fruit Cove – A Nature Lover’s Paradise
Fruit Cove is a scenic community along the St. Johns River, offering a peaceful environment with beautiful waterfront views. It's also close to World Golf Village, which is considered a golfer's paradise.
As one of the best neighborhoods in St. Johns County, Florida, it boasts stunning natural beauty and a variety of outdoor activities, including boating, fishing, and hiking. This makes it a prime destination for outdoor enthusiasts. The area is also home to highly rated schools and a strong sense of community, attracting families looking for a safe and welcoming environment.
Investors can find spacious homes on large lots, providing excellent opportunities to cater to families and retirees seeking a peaceful yet convenient lifestyle.
Investment Potential: Fruit Cove offers stable property values and high rental demand from people who want to raise a family and seek a quiet yet convenient location near Jacksonville.
3. St. Augustine Beach – A High-Demand Vacation Rental Market
St. Augustine Beach presents a golden opportunity for investors interested in short-term rentals with its tourist appeal and beachfront properties.
St. Augustine Beach boasts miles of pristine beaches and breathtaking oceanfront views, attracting visitors year-round. The area has a thriving short-term rental market, making it an excellent location for Airbnb or vacation home investments. Its proximity to historic downtown St. Augustine provides residents and visitors with a unique mix of history, shopping, and dining, further enhancing its appeal.
Investment Potential: Beachfront properties tend to appreciate in value and offer strong cash flow for investors focused on vacation rentals.
4. Beacon Lake – A Growing Family Community
Beacon Lake is a newer master-planned community designed with families in mind. As one of the best neighborhoods in St. Johns County, Florida, it offers modern amenities and convenient access to shopping and entertainment, creating a vibrant and active community.
- Some of its standout features include:
- Competition pool
- Splash park
- Clubhouse
- Top shopping centers like Johns Town Center
The neighborhood also features modern home designs at attractive prices, making it an excellent choice for first-time homebuyers and investors alike.
Investment Potential: Beacon Lake’s popularity continues to grow, making it a promising area for real estate appreciation and rental demand.
5. Palm Valley – A Hidden Gem for Outdoor Enthusiasts
Palm Valley offers luxury homes and more affordable options, surrounded by nature preserves and waterfront views.
Its proximity to Ponte Vedra Beach makes it a desirable location for high-end renters seeking luxury coastal living. The area offers stunning lake views, scenic hiking trails, and a peaceful atmosphere, attracting nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts.
Investors can choose from diverse property types, including waterfront homes, luxury estates, and single-family residences, providing excellent opportunities for long-term appreciation.
Investment Potential: Palm Valley is perfect for investors targeting high-end buyers and long-term rental tenants.
6. Ponte Vedra – A High-Value Luxury Market
Ponte Vedra is one of Northeast Florida’s most prestigious neighborhoods. It is known for its world-class golf courses and upscale properties. As one of the best neighborhoods in St. Johns County, Florida, it attracts luxury homebuyers and investors seeking high-value real estate opportunities.
The neighborhood is home to some of the best golf courses in Florida, including the renowned TPC Sawgrass, making it a top choice for golf enthusiasts and luxury homebuyers. It also features exclusive gated communities with resort-style amenities, offering residents a high standard of living.
With excellent schools and consistently high property appreciation rates, Ponte Vedra is a prime location for long-term real estate investment.
Investment Potential: Ponte Vedra offers some of the highest returns on investment, making it ideal for long-term growth and luxury rental income.
7. Vilano Beach – Affordable Waterfront Living
For investors looking for coastal properties at a reasonable price, Vilano Beach provides a mix of affordability and luxury. It’s also close to the historic St. Augustine, providing strong rental demand for the properties around the area.
Property owners and renters can also enjoy nearby active lifestyle amenities, such as:
- Intracoastal Waterway access ideal for boating and fishing.
- Parks
- Beaches
- Walking trails
Investment Potential: Vilano Beach is a smart first investment choice with steady property appreciation and demand from vacationers and retirees.
8. Del Webb Nocatee – A Premier 55+ Community
Del Webb Nocatee is one of Florida’s top active adult communities, perfect for investors targeting retirees and snowbirds.
As one of the best neighborhoods in St. Johns County, Florida, it offers an exclusive 55+ lifestyle with a high demand for both rental and resale properties. It features resort-style amenities, including swimming pools, fitness centers, and two amenity centers, creating a vibrant and active environment for residents.
Its low-maintenance homes make it an attractive option for retirees seeking convenience and comfort.
Investment Potential: With Florida’s aging population and demand for retirement-friendly housing, Del Webb Nocatee offers steady rental income and strong resale value.
9. Durbin Crossing – A Fast-Growing Community
Durbin Crossing is one of the most rapidly developing neighborhoods in St. Johns County, attracting families and young professionals. The vibrant community has extensive recreational areas and facilities that include:
- Soccer fields
- Competition pool
- Family pool
- Basketball courts
- An aquatic complex
- Johns Town Center
- Downtown Jacksonville
This neighborhood has top-rated schools, making it an excellent choice for families seeking a high-quality education for their children.
Investment Potential: Property values are expected to rise as Durbin Crossing expands, making it an excellent long-term investment.
Find the Best Rental Investments in St. Johns County with Property Management Experts
St. Johns County remains one of Florida’s most desirable real estate markets, offering strong investment potential, excellent schools, and a high quality of life. Whether you are searching for a family-friendly neighborhood, a profitable vacation rental, or a peaceful retirement retreat, this region provides various options to meet your goals. With stunning beaches, top-rated schools, and master-planned communities featuring resort-style amenities, investing in St. Johns County is a smart move for any property investor.
Round Table Property Management specializes in helping investors find and manage the best rental properties in St. Johns County. Our expert services include:
- FREE ROI Calculator – Helps you confidently assess the financial viability of your investment.
- Tenant Placement – Find high-quality tenants quickly and efficiently.
- Full-Service Property Management – Handles all aspects of rental management, from maintenance to lease enforcement.
- Investment Guidance – Helps you choose the right properties for long-term growth and profitability.
Let us guide you to the best opportunities and take the stress out of property management. Start building a successful investment portfolio today!
Related Articles
Top Ways to Boost Energy Efficiency in St. Johns County Rentals
Essential Tips for First-Time Landlords
A Real Estate Investor's Guide to Simplifying Owner Disbursements
